Why Older Homes in Pittsburgh Are More Likely to Need Foundation Repair

Pittsburgh is known for its rich history, beautiful architecture, and charming older homes—but with that character often comes a set of hidden challenges. One of the most common (and costly) issues in older homes? Foundation problems.

At A Better Choice, Inc., we specialize in foundation repair throughout Pittsburgh and Western PA. We’ve seen firsthand how time, environment, and outdated building practices can wreak havoc on a home’s structural integrity. If you live in a house that’s 50, 75, or even 100+ years old, here’s what you need to know.

1. Outdated Building Materials and Methods

Many of Pittsburgh’s historic homes were built with materials that simply don’t hold up to today’s standards:

• Stone or brick foundations without reinforced concrete

• Lime-based mortar instead of modern, weather-resistant mixes

• Shallow footings that don’t reach the frost line

While these materials were strong for their time, they are vulnerable to shifting soil, moisture intrusion, and natural deterioration—especially without modern waterproofing.

2. Pittsburgh’s Wet Climate Isn’t Helping

Western Pennsylvania experiences frequent rain, heavy snow, and freeze-thaw cycles—all of which put serious stress on home foundations. Older homes often lack:

• Proper drainage systems

• Functional gutters and downspouts

• Waterproofing membranes on exterior walls

Without these protections, water slowly seeps into cracks and joints, weakening the structure over time. If your old home has a damp or musty basement, that’s a major red flag.

3. Settling and Shifting Over Time

Every home settles a little over the years, but older homes have had decades (or centuries) to shift. Natural settling can lead to:

• Cracks in foundation walls and basement floors

• Uneven floors or doors that won’t close properly

• Gaps between walls and ceilings

Combine this with Pittsburgh’s hilly terrain and clay-heavy soils, and it’s easy to see why so many older homes here need structural attention.

4. Neglected Maintenance or DIY Repairs

Let’s face it—many older homes have passed through several owners. Some may have done DIY patch jobs instead of addressing the root problems. We frequently see:

• Paint or plaster hiding wall cracks

• Temporary jack posts in basements

• Outdated sump pumps or drainage systems that no longer work properly

If past repairs weren’t done right, the underlying issues continue to grow—and that foundation damage doesn’t fix itself.

5. Lack of Modern Waterproofing Solutions

Most older homes weren’t built with interior drain tile systems, sump pumps, or vapor barriers. That makes them particularly vulnerable to water intrusion, especially as the foundation materials age and become more porous. Today’s foundation repair solutions are far more advanced and effective, but older homes are still relying on outdated or nonexistent systems.

How A Better Choice, Inc. Can Help

At A Better Choice, Inc., we’ve built a reputation in the Pittsburgh region for expert foundation repair and basement waterproofing, especially in older and historic homes.

Our services include:

• Foundation crack repair

• Bowing wall stabilization

• Push pier and helical pier installation

• Interior & exterior waterproofing systems

• Sump pump installation and drainage correction

We don’t just treat the symptoms—we diagnose the cause and fix it right, using modern materials that stand the test of time.

Signs Your Older Home May Need Foundation Repair

• Cracks in foundation walls or floors

• Leaning or bowing basement walls

• Uneven or sloping floors

• Doors or windows sticking

• Water intrusion or musty odors

If you're noticing any of these signs, it’s time to schedule a professional inspection.

Serving Pittsburgh’s Historic Homes with Care

From the stately Victorians in Shadyside to the brick four-squares in Mt. Lebanon and the charming row homes of Lawrenceville, we know the unique needs of Pittsburgh’s older housing stock. Our team approaches every project with respect for the home’s history—and a plan to protect its future.

Let’s Preserve Your Home for the Next 100 Years

Don’t let foundation problems compromise the safety or value of your beloved older home. Contact A Better Choice, Inc. today to schedule your free inspection and get expert advice you can trust.

Because when it comes to your home’s foundation, making the better choice today can save you thousands tomorrow.